4 February, 2023 Revista Digital sobre Patentes, Marcas y Propiedad Intelectual

Traditional and new Domain Name rights protection mechanisms

Captura de pantalla 2016-02-02 a las 16.36.59

By Arturo Ishbak Gonzalez

Trademark use on the Internet has increased significantly in the last years and nowadays it is considered an essential tool for companies to promote their products and/or services among the consumers. Consequently, it is not surprising to find unscrupulous people who register Domain Names identical or confusingly similar to registered trademarks in order to obtain economic benefits by selling them to their legitimate owners. This practice, aka cybersquatting has been defined as a “generally bad faith registration of another’s trademark in a domain name.”[i]

 

In this regard, this article will analyze the mechanisms, similarities and differences between two efficient and inexpensive alternatives to deal with cybersquatting: the traditional Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy system (“UDRP”) and the new Uniform Rapid Suspension system (“URS”).

 

First, it is important to identify the Domain Name Registration Hierarchy because the use of the technical terms might be confusing:

 

  • Organization such as Verisign in charge of database of domains ending with a top-level domain name (including gTLDs such as .com or .net and ccTLDs such as .us or .mx).
  • Organizations such as CSC, Network Solutions, or GoDaddy that sells rights to use a particular second-level domains (such as mipatente.com).

 

  • User who purchases right to use a second-level domain for a designated period of time (e.g., Grupo Selco for the mipatente.com domain name).

 

In 1999, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) introduced the UDRP. ICANN is a global multi-stakeholder organization that collaborates with companies, individuals, and governments to ensure the continued security, stability, and interoperability of the Internet.

 

The UDRP allows for resolution of dispute over use of another’s trademark in a Domain Name. Since there is no mechanism for discovery or testimony, the timeframe from filing the complaint to final decision is relatively short; approximately two months.

 

All gTLDs are subject to ICANN’s rules. Upon registration of such a Domain Name, the registrant agrees to submit to the mandatory arbitration requirements of ICANN. Unlike gTLD’s, country code top-level domains (ccTLDs) are not all subject to ICANN’s rules, unless the country has agreed to adopt the policy.

 

There are different dispute resolution providers: Word Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), the National Arbitration Forum (NAF), Asian Domain Name Dispute Resolution Centre (ADNDRC), Czech Arbitration Court Center for Internet Disputes, and Arab Center for Domain Name Dispute Resolution (ACDR).

 

The Complainant can pick one or three arbitrators to decide the case and costs range from approximately USD $1,300 to USD $4,500 in fees charged by the providers, not including legal fees incurred by the litigants. Thus, the UDRP proceeding is relatively inexpensive and an efficient alternative for stopping cybersquatters.

 

The complaint, filed directly with the dispute resolution provider, must specify the Domain Name at issue, the respondent or holder of the Domain Name, the registrar with whom the Domain Name was registered and the grounds for the complaint. To prevail, a Complainant must show that:

 

  1. the domain name is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark or service mark in which the complainant has rights;
  2. the registrant has no rights or legitimate interests in the domain name; and
  • the domain name was registered and is being used in bad faith.

 

On the other hand, the URS system was introduced as an alternative to the UDRP system to provide more rapid relief to trademark owners in clear-cut Domain Name disputes. The entire URS process generally takes between 20 to 25 days and the elements to prevail in a URS complaint are the same as for a UDRP complaint.

 

Whereas the UDRP applies to all gTLDs (and ccTLDs that have adopted it), the URS applies only to new gTLDs such as .GENERIC (.law) and .BRAND (.netflix) or ccTLDs that have adopted the URS. Currently, the URS has only been adopted in relation to the .pw ccTLD (i.e., Palau). So far, only the ADNDRC and the NAF have been appointed by ICANN as URS providers.

 

Regarding the filing fees for the URS, they are much lower than for the UDRP. For example, if the complaint involves one to five Domain Names, the ADNDRC sets the filing fee for the URS at USD 360 and for the UDRP at USD 1,500 (for a single-member panel).

 

Now, the remedies available for UDRP are cancellation or transfer of the Domain Name at issue, damages and injunction are not available. UDRP however contains the possibility of filing a lawsuit against the Registrant in a jurisdiction that is either the location of WIPO’s principal office or Respondent’s address as shown in the “whois” database.

 

In the US, the Anti-Cybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (ACPA) traditionally awards the prevailing party with USD $1,000 to $100,000 for trademark / statutory damages per infringing domain name.

 

Finally, the sole remedy available to a Complainant in a URS is the suspension of the Domain Name. Unlike UDRP proceedings, the panelists cannot order the transfer of the Domain Name to the Complainant or cancel the registration of the Domain Name. If the panelists issue a determination in favor of the Complainant, the “whois” details will continue to show the respondent as the registrant, but the Domain Name will be suspended from use and will automatically redirect users to a page stating that the Domain Name is not available and has been taken down as a result of a URS action. The Domain Name cannot be transferred, deleted or modified during the life of the registration, and the Complainant itself is not entitled to use it.

 

The suspension is for the remainder of the registration period of the respective Domain Name. The Complainant can extend the suspension for an additional year by extending the registration period and paying the renewal registration fees. However, once the Domain Name expires and ceases to be suspended, there is nothing to stop another third party from re-registering the Domain Name.

[i] https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/cybersquatting-2013-05-03-en

 

Arturo Ishbak Gonzalez

NBC Tower, Suite 3600, 455 N. Cityfront Plaza Drive

Chicago, Illinois 60611-5599

[email protected] Twitter: @ArturoIshbak

Comparte tu opinión sobre este artículo

Comentarios

Related Posts

Conoce el laboratorio donde se desarrollan coches autónomos

3 julio, 2017

3 julio, 2017

Por Armando Bonilla Ciudad de México.  (Agencia informativa Conacyt).- Contar con robots totalmente autónomos que faciliten e incluso suplan al...

Despegue de la bioenergía en el sureste

13 octubre, 2018

13 octubre, 2018

Por Marytere Narváez Mérida, Yucatán.  (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- En 2015, la Secretaría de Energía (Sener) implementó la Estrategia de Transición...

Desarrolla ingeniero del IPN sistema para traducción de señas

18 febrero, 2016

18 febrero, 2016

AUTOR: Erika Socorro Rodríguez FUENTE: AGENCIA INFORMATIVA CONACYT Zacatecas, Zacatecas. 16 de febrero de 2016 (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Con la finalidad de...

México realizará innovación con Israel

20 abril, 2016

20 abril, 2016

Ciudad de México. 14 de abril de 2016 (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Para impulsar las colaboraciones científicas y tecnológicas de México con...

Prótesis biónicas con sentido social

10 octubre, 2017

10 octubre, 2017

Por Karla Navarro Ensenada, Baja California. (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- El Instituto Tecnológico de Rehabilitación (ITR) es una organización no gubernamental,...

La transferencia de tecnología como elemento para la competitividad

24 agosto, 2016

24 agosto, 2016

AUTOR: Ana Luisa Guerrero FUENTE: AGENCIA INFORMATIVA CONACYT Ciudad de México.  (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Vincular a los creadores del conocimiento y...

El poder analgésico de la guanábana

5 mayo, 2016

5 mayo, 2016

San Luis Potosí, San Luis Potosí. (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Alumnos de la Facultad de Ciencias Químico Biológicas de la Universidad Autónoma de...

Biofiltros para granjas camaroneras

4 agosto, 2016

4 agosto, 2016

AUTOR: Claudia Karina Gómez FUENTE: AGENCIA INFORMATIVA CONACYT Tepic, Nayarit.  (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Con la finalidad de mejorar la producción camaronera en...

Conocimiento que trasciende, obtiene UNAM cinco nuevas patentes

1 abril, 2016

1 abril, 2016

AUTOR: Carmen Báez FUENTE: AGENCIA INFORMATIVA CONACYT   Ciudad de México. 23 de marzo de 2016 (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Una vocación importante...

Trump da tregua de tres meses para el veto a Huawei

21 mayo, 2019

21 mayo, 2019

La tregua retrasa hasta el 19 de agosto el veto con el que el gigante chino dejaría de recibir suministros estadounidenses

Inaugura la UAM laboratorio para el diseño sustentable

5 junio, 2017

5 junio, 2017

* Ese espacio de la Unidad Cuajimalpa promueve la adquisición y la difusión del conocimiento colaborativo * Ofrece un sitio...

Diseñan sistema para generar electricidad en ríos más grandes del mundo

22 abril, 2016

22 abril, 2016

AUTOR: Jorge Armando Bonilla FUENTE:  AGENCIA INFORMATIVA CONACYT Ciudad de México.  (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- El cambio climático es cada vez más evidente...

Iniciativas tecnológicas para apoyar a jóvenes mexicanos

17 mayo, 2016

17 mayo, 2016

AUTOR: Ana Luisa Guerrero vFUENTE:  AGENCIA INFORMATIVA CONACYT Ciudad de México.  (Agencia Informativa Conacyt).- Un cuarto de la población mexicana es joven,...

Lanzan convocatoria conjunta Conacyt-British Council México

18 septiembre, 2016

18 septiembre, 2016

Si tienes un desarrollo tecnológico en áreas de:  Agua, Seguridad Alimentaria y Desarrollo Económico Ambiental, Infraestructura, Nanotecnología, Materiales para el...

Volkswagen de México ofrece espacios para prácticas profesionales

8 julio, 2017

8 julio, 2017

FUENTE: Asociación Nacional de Universidades e Instituciones de Educación Superior, ANUIES, www.anuies.mx Para alumnos universitarios mexicanos, en varias áreas del...